Salzmann Nodular Degeneration
Salzmann’s nodular degeneration SND is a slowly progressive condition in which gray-white to bluish nodules measuring 1-3 mm are seen anterior to Bowman’s layer of the cornea, usually bilaterally,,. These elevated nodules can be located near the limbus or in the mid-peripheral cornea.
There has not been a specific causal etiology described to date. Anecdotal evidence suggests that this disease can occur following chronic corneal disorders; however, many cases appear to be idiopathic, arising in patients with no history of keratitis. Genetic causes have also been described.
Meibomian gland dysfunction is the most common coexistent condition. SND has been shown to co-occur in patients with a history of ocular surface disease, including phlyctenulosis, vernal keratoconjunctivitis, interstitial keratitis, trachoma, scarlet fever, measles, and other viral diseases. SND can also occur in patients with chronically dry eyes, chronic blepharitis, trichiasis, previous ocular trauma, and post-operatively (including after cataract removal),. SND has also been described in association with Crohn’s disease. Additional associations that have been postulated include contact lens use and peripheral vascularization of the cornea.
72%-88% of cases occur in females. SND is more common in Caucasian women in the 6th decade of life but can be seen in both males and females of all ages beginning near adolescence. The disease is seen bilaterally in 58%-67% of cases.
In vivo confocal microscopy reveals a normal epithelium in the central cornea with rare sub-basal nerve fibers that display increased thickness and lack branching. Occasionally seen around these fibers are reflective cellular elements. Nerve fibers in the corneal stroma are also abnormal in that their branches are very thick and tortuous with highly reflective segments and contain “tracts with granular aspect”. These abnormal stromal nerves resemble regenerating nerves that can be seen after penetrating keratoplasty. Deep stroma and endothelial components do not appear to be altered. The peripheral zone of Salzmann nodules displays basal epithelial cells that appear abnormally elongated. Highly reflective structures (representing activated keratocytes) are present in both the peripheral zone and in the subepithelial stroma of the central portion of the nodules.
Light microscopy (figure 1) reveals dense deposits of hyalinized, irregularly arranged collagen fibers anterior to a fragmented and sometimes absent Bowman’s layer,. The tissue overlying the Salzmann nodules displays an attenuated epithelium containing only 1-2 layers of discontinuous, elongated basal cells in addition to 2-3 more hyperchromatic layers above it. The corneal stroma contains unevenly distributed keratocytes and disorganized collagen bundles. The keratocytes seen in the nodular stroma have not been shown to be mitotically active; rather, they resemble activated fibroblasts or myofibroblasts of the anterior stroma during corneal repair.
Morphometric analysis yields a thinned corneal epithelium (2-4 fold) overlying the Salzmann nodules.
One hypothesis suggests that enzymatic destruction of Bowman’s layer results in migration and proliferation of keratocytes from the posterior stroma, resulting in secondary deposition of extracellular matrix components in nodular areas.
Salzmann nodules consist of a hypercellular area of extracellular matrix seen between a thinned overlying corneal epithelium and a fragmented or absent Bowman’s layer. Cellular elements within these nodules stain with vimentin (similar to fibroblasts). The basal epithelial cells that overly the nodules stain negatively for matrix metalloproteinase-9 but positively for matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2). MMP-2 is not normally expressed in terminally differentiated epithelium of the central cornea. This protein has the ability to dissolve collagen type IV, which is the main component of the corneal epithelial basement membrane. The expression of MMP-2 by the basal epithelial cells overlying Salzmann nodules suggests that these cells may be contributing to the destruction of Bowman’s layer, subsequently resulting in migration and proliferation of keratocytes and deposition of extracellular matrix in nodular areas. It has been hypothesized that MMP-2 overexpression in the basal epithelial cells overlying Salzmann nodules occurs by induction due to an elevating nodule; however, it is unclear exactly what then could have caused the nodule to appear in the first place.
Immunohistochemical analysis of protein expression in the basal epithelial cells suggests that these cells have a high metabolic activity—a feature also seen in the transient amplifying epithelial cells of the limbus. This finding implicates the involvement of the epithelial cells in the formation of the subepithelial collagen elements seen in Salzmann nodules. This in turn correlates with the clinical association that has been described linking chronic ocular surface disease (affecting the corneal epithelium) with the development of SND.
Additionally, an autoimmune etiology has also been suggested in terms of the pathogenesis of SND.
Regardless of the biochemical mechanisms responsible for the pathogenesis of this disease, SND can result in clinically apparent astigmatism due to the nature of its characteristic nodular pattern.
The diagnosis of SND is usually made clinically. Slit lamp exam can show grey-white to bluish nodules posterior to the corneal epithelium. These nodules can occasionally stain with fluorescein (figure 2). Corneal topography can reveal significant irregular astigmatism occurring as a result of Salzmann nodules (figure 3).
History and Physical Examination
These patients usually present with gradual, painless loss of vision—both near-vision and distance-vision. They may or may not have a history of chronic ocular surface disease such as that described above. Patients may also complain of a “foreign body sensation” on the surface of their eye. Slit lamp exam can reveal white to bluish-grey nodules within the cornea (figure 4).
Corneal scarring and astigmatism, spheroidal degeneration, or corneal abrasion can present with a similar deterioration of visual acuity.
Spontaneous resolution has not been reported to date—treatment involves either medical management or surgical removal of the nodular lesions, depending on the patient’s clinical picture. Surgical treatment (when indicated) usually results in rapid improvement of visual acuity.
Conservative treatment can involve management of the potentially underlying etiology (if known).
Medical management, which successfully treats most patients, may include ocular lubrication, steroid eye drops, warm compresses and proper eyelid hygiene.
Surgical indications include ocular discomfort (i.e, usually a “foreign body sensation”) or reduced visual acuity due to irregular astigmatism.
Superficial keratectomy successfully results in improved visual acuity in 90% of cases. Recurrences are very common (about 22% after a mean follow-up time of 61 months); however, recurrences significant enough to impact vision may only occur in 5-20% of cases. If visually significant anterior stromal haze persists after superficial keratectomy, phototherapeutic keratectomy can be used as an adjunct therapy.
In some cases, superficial keratectomy can easily separate elevated nodular tissue from the corneal surface, leaving Bowman’s layer (where present) untouched. These operations are followed by subsequent phototherapeutic keratectomy in order to create a homogeneous cornea. Recurrence is rare with such cases. Phototherapeutic keratectomy can be performed with or without topical mitomycin-C; however, this procedure can induce a myopic shift.
Other cases, which are often complicated with major peripheral vascularization, involve difficult-to-remove nodules and are left with deeper defects in Bowman’s layer and the superficial stroma after superficial keratectomy. These cases may require several masking/laser ablation procedures post-operatively in order to create a smooth surface. Laser ablation done properly in these cases usually prevents the need for lamellar and penetrating keratoplasty. Recurrences occur more frequently in these cases.
Anterior lamellar keratoplasty is rarely required. Generally, it is only performed when Salzmann nodules are seen extending to or past the mid-stroma. However, keratoplasty may not necessarily be a perfect cure for this disease. A 1990 study performed by Severin and Kirchoff demonstrated that not only can a late epithelial immune response be observed within 18 months of keratoplasty, but the procedure can also be followed by evidence of incomplete re-epithelisation and the development of superficial cloudy opacities within 2.5-9 years.
The subepithelial nodules that characterize this disease can irritate the ocular surface resulting in secondary recurrent corneal erosions, photophobia, blepharospasm, and tearing. The nodules themselves can also create a relatively steepened mid-peripheral cornea and a flatter central cornea, resulting in hyperopic visual changes. It has been demonstrated that SND causes more significant astigmatism in patients whose disease affects multiple corneal quadrants; consequently, these patients are more likely to require surgical treatment. Peripheral corneal vascularization can also occur in 7% to 31% of patients,; however, this complication could actually be a result of the original pathology causing SND rather than being due to SND itself. This is a potentially important complication since it is more commonly associated with nodules that are more difficult to remove.
- American Academy of Ophthalmology. Salzmann nodular degeneration Practicing Ophthalmologists Learning System, 2017 - 2019 San Francisco: American Academy of Ophthalmology, 2017.
- Roszkowska AM, Aragona P, Spinella R, Pisani A, Puzzolo D, Micali A. Morphologic and Confocal Investigation on Salzmann Nodular Degeneration of the Cornea. 2011;52(8):5910-5919.
- Salzmann M. Uebereine Abart der knoetchen foermigen Hornhaut dystrophie. Zeitschriftfuer Augenheilk unde 1925;57:92–99.
- Hamada S, Darrad K, McDonnell P. Salzmann’s Nodular Corneal Degeneration: Clinical Findings, Risk Factors, Prognosis and the Role of Previous Contact Lens Wear. Contact lens and Anterior Eye. 2011 Aug;34(4):173-8.
- Eberwein P, Hiss S, Auw-Haedrich C, Sundmacher R, Hauer K, Boehringer D, Meier P, Reinhard T. Epithelial Marker Expression in Salzmann Nodular Degeneration Shows Characteristics of LimbalTransient Amplifying Cells and Alludes to an Involvement of the Epithelium in its Pathogenesis. ActaOphthalmologica. 2010 88:e184–e189.
- Das S, Link B, Seitz B. Department of Ophthalmology, University of Erlangen-Nurnberg, Erlangen, Germany; and ECOS Eye Hospital Berhampur, Orissa, India. Salzmann's Nodular Degeneration of the Cornea: A Review and Case Series. Cornea. 2005;24(7):772-777.
- Yoon KC, Park YG. Recurrent Salzmann’s Nodular Degeneration. Jpn J Ophthalmol.2003;47(4):401-4.
- Graue-Hernández EO, Mannis MJ, Eliasieh K, Greasby TA, Beckett LA, Bradley JC, Schwab IR. Salzmann Nodular Degeneration. Cornea. 2010;29(3):283-9.
- Lange AP, Bahar I, Sansanayudh W, Kaisermann I, Slomovic AR. Salzmann Nodules—a Possible New Ocular Manifestation of Crohn’s Disease: a case report. Cornea. 2009;28(1):85-6.
- Carroll JN, Maltry AC, Kitzmann AS. Salzmann’s Nodular Corneal Degeneration: 62-year-old woman presents with 3 years of progressive decrease in vision. EyeRounds.org. September 9, 2013; available from http://EyeRounds.org/cases/180-salzmann-nodular-corneal-degeneration.htm. Accessed [Feb 14, 2015].
- Severin M, Kirchhof B. Recurrent Salzmann’s Nodular Degeneration. Graefes Arch ClinExpOphthalmol. 1990;228(2):101-4.
- Müller LJ, Pels L, Vrensen GF. Ultrastructural Organization of Human Corneal Nerves. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 1996;37:476–488.
- Meltendorf C, Bühren J, Bug R, Ohrloff C, Kohnen T. Correlation Between Clinical in Vivo Confocal Microscopic and Ex Vivo Histopathologic Findings of Salzmann Nodular Degeneration. Cornea. 2006;25(6):734-8.
- Ocular Pathology Atlas. American Academy of Ophthalmology Web site. https://www.aao.org/resident-course/pathology-atlas. Published 2016. Accessed January 4, 2017.
- Stone D, Astley R, Shaver R, Chodosh J. Histopathology of Salzmann Nodular Corneal Degeneration. Cornea. 2008;27(2):148-51.
- Khaireddin R, Katz T, Baile R, Richard G, Linke SJ. Superficial Keratectomy, PTK, and Mitomycin C as a Combined Treatment Option for Salzmann’s Nodular Degeneration: A Follow-up of Eight Eyes. Graefe’s Archive for Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology. 2011;249(8):1211-15.
- Farjo AA, Halperin GI, Syed N, Sutphin JE, Wagoner MD. Salzmann’s Nodular Corneal Degeneration Clinical Characteristics and Surgical Outcomes. Cornea. 2006;25(1):11-5.